The EL TORO Tragedy
An Independent Review of
the Coast Guard Investigation Report
by David H. Pascoe, Marine Surveyor
Introduction - Part I - Part II - Part III - Part IVIntroduction
On December 5, 1993 the party fishing vessel EL TORO II sprung three planks and sank 5 miles south of Point Lookout on the Chesapeake Bay. There were 23 passengers aboard and three died in the incident, mainly due to exposure to the cold bay waters.
The EL TORO is a story of particular interest to marine surveyors that
reveals some hard-learned lessons. EL TORO was a Coast Guard certified
passenger carrying vessel that had just undergone its drydock inspection
on March 23, 1993, little more than 8 months prior. In addition, an
insurance survey was completed just 5 days before the loss of the EL TORO.
Both of these are factors which will come into play, as we shall soon see,
that provide some very important lessons for surveyors.
This review is based solely upon the U.S.C.G. investigation report dated
29 July, 1994 and subsequently published on the Internet. The report runs
34 pages in length and will only be excerpted here, not be reproduced in
whole. It is available on the U.S.C.G web site for anyone interested at http://www.uscg.mil/hq/gm/moa/boards/eltoroII.pdf (*). This
review is intended solely for the purpose of analysis of a tragedy and how
marine surveyors may learn from it and better perform their services. This
writer recognizes that he does not have all the facts, and that any
criticism herein is based solely on the published report. This is not a
complete investigation of the incident and should not be interpreted as
such.
The names of the participants have been changed to protect their
identities. (NEXT)
Contents
(*)The pdf file address is updated - May 2, 2015.
First posted 5/11/97 at David Pascoe's site www.yachtsurvey.com.
Page design changed this site.
Professional Marine Surveys
- Hull Design Defects - Part I
- Hull Design Defects - Part II
- Surveying Boats With Molded Integral Grid Systems
- Surveying Wood Hulls
- Avoiding the Blister Blues
- Sinking of EL TORO II
- Storm Damaged Boats
- Insurance Surveys and Reports
Power Boat Books
A Guide for Discriminating Buyers
Focuses exclusively cruiser class generally 30-55 feet
With discussions on the pros and cons of each type: Expresses, trawlers, motor yachts, multi purpose types, sportfishermen and sedan cruisers.
Selecting and Evaluating New and Used Boats
Dedicated for offshore outboard boats
A hard and realistic look at the marine market place and delves into issues of boat quality and durability that most other marine writers are unwilling to touch.
2nd Edition
The Art of Pre-Purchase Survey The very first of its kind, this book provides the essentials that every novice needs to know, as well as a wealth of esoteric details.
Pleasure crafts investigations to court testimony The first and only book of its kind on the subject of investigating pleasure craft casualties and other issues.